You’re interviewing candidates for a position on your team. The three finalists appear to be equally qualified, but you discover that one of them graduated from your alma mater. Suddenly you have a slight preference for that candidate.
Implicit egotism is exerting its influence.
Implicit egotism refers to the idea that we naturally gravitate toward people, places, and things that resemble ourselves. We unconsciously choose ego-friendly things. This preference for self drives a lot of our thinking and decisions.
For example, we strongly prefer the letters in our name, the numbers in our birthdate, and memorable moments in our life.
- A person named Fred might be attracted to the notion of living in Fresno, working for Forever 21, or driving a Ford F-150.
- We may use the year we were born as an anchor-point for remembering other dates. For example, I remember the date of the Yom Kippur War (1973) as being 21 years after I was born in 1952.
- A man proposed to his future wife at Logan Airport, and they named their first child Logan.
- When I first met my wife, I was intrigued by the fact that we were both born at Baylor Hospital in Dallas.
- My grandson, Ben, will probably develop a preference to the letters B, E, N, because they are the first letters he learned and every time he writes his name those letters are reinforced in his mind.
Implicit egotism is not inherently wrong, unless it adversely affects our decisions. In my opening example, the candidate that has the same alma mater as the interviewer should not be preferred—it’s a weak link. Likewise, I don’t think Fred should purchase a Ford F-150 just because it starts with the same letter of his name.
In his book, The Art of Thinking Clearly, Rolf Dobelli gives this example of implicit egotism: “A friend who deals in oil pumps told me how he once closed an eight-figure deal for a pipeline in Russia. ‘Bribery?’ I inquired? He shook his head. ‘We were chatting, and suddenly we got on to the topic of sailing. It turned out that both of us were die-hard 470 dinghy fans. From that moment on, he liked me; I was a friend. So the deal was sealed.'” (page 66)
When making decisions, make sure implicit egotism is not adversely influencing the process. And when you’re selling something, look for a personal connection with the buyer.
8 Replies to “Implicit egotism”
So true, Don! I think this often also rings true with regard to the nepotism of leaders who hire family, because “no one does it better.” Thanks for this candid look inside our hearts.
Wayne, I had not thought about implicit egotism being associate with nepotism, but the connection is there. Thanks.
Great article, Don. That happens all the time…whether consciously, subconsciously or unconsciously. Wise to be aware.
Thanks, Neil, for taking the time to write. It is an insightful and helpful concept. Take care, Don.
I know a couple who are motorcyclists and named their baby son Harley.
That’s a classic example of implicit egotism. Thanks.
As a recruitment officer, I was intrigued by the idea of implicit egotism. I recently had a preferred candidate as I saw her as professional and strong minded but my two other interview panel members preferred the candidate with better qualifications and experience who was quieter and less determined. I felt that I had to bow to their view as my preferred candidate would need much more training. However, only time will tell if the candidate is cut-out for the stresses of the job.
Thanks, Angela, for taking the time to write. Hiring people is the most important function of leadership. It’s difficult. I think if 70% of our hires work out our “batting average” is above par.